Hospital bosses deny suppressing Letby concerns
Executives at the hospital where Lucy Letby attacked and killed babies have told a public inquiry they had never tried to âsuppress concernsâ about the nurse.
However, the four former senior managers at the Countess of Chester Hospital said they were âdeeply sorryâ to her victimsâ families for âkeeping them in the darkâ.
While they stressed they had had no suspicions regarding foul play on the part of the nurse before June 2016, they apologised for a delay in contacting police after Letby was removed from front-line duty.
The Thirlwall Inquiry, at Liverpool Town Hall, heard none of the four managers had previously experienced âsuch criminal behaviourâ over the course of their long careers.
Kate Blackwell KC spoke on behalf of former chief executive Tony Chambers, former medical director Ian Harvey, former director of nursing Alison Kelly, and ex-HR director Susan Hodkinson.
On Thursday, lawyers representing the families of babies injured or murdered by Letby criticised the managers for failing to investigate concerns raised by consultants working in the hospitalâs neonatal unit.
During Letbyâs criminal trial, key witness Dr Ravi Jayaram told the jury that he and his fellow consultants were under a âreasonable amount of pressure from senior management at the hospital not to make a fussâ.
However, Ms Blackwell told inquiry chair Lady Justice Thirlwall: âAt no time did the senior managers seek to suppress concerns or attempts to blow the whistle.
âAnd it will be a matter of exploration for this inquiry as to why those who held concerns about criminality did not contact the NMC, the police, or any of the other relevant external bodies.â
The consultants involved have not yet addressed the inquiry on this point, but are due to give evidence in the coming weeks.
Ms Blackwell said senior managers felt they had âtaken appropriate stepsâ based on the information they had received at the time about rising death rates in the hospitalâs neonatal unit.
They recognised, however, that contact with some parents âwas inadequate, both in terms of frequency and manner, and that this has caused hurt and anxieties to those affectedâ.
The managers stated that, when made aware that Letby was on shift during many unexplained deaths and collapses in health, they were told it was likely due to the nurseâs âspecialist trainingâ and her willingness to do extra shifts.
They said neonatal unit manager Eirian Powell was also âfirmly of the view that Letby was a good and competent nurseâ.
The inquiry heard Mr Chambers, Ms Kelly, Mr Harvey and Ms Hodkinson had worked in healthcare for many years but had ânever come across such criminal behaviourâ.
âThat a nurse could be responsible for these heinous crimes is profoundly disturbing,â Ms Blackwell said.
âIt is not something that any of us ever expected to be happening on the neonatal ward of the hospital, it being so against the natural order of what was contemplated or foreseen.â
The inquiry also heard an opening statement on behalf of NHS England, which criticised the Countess of Chester Hospital for under-reporting serious incidents in its neonatal unit.
Jason Beer KC, on behalf of NHS England, told the inquiry: âIt seems to be generally acknowledged that there was under-reporting of incidents on the neonatal unit.â
Mr Beer said NHS England acknowledged it âcould have done moreâ to scrutinise the hospital when death rates on the unit became a concern.
Letby, from Hereford, is serving 15 whole-life prison terms after she was convicted in August 2023 of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others between June 2015 and June 2016.
The inquiry continues.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas to northwest.newsonline@bbc.co.uk