Police feel unsafe working at carnival, survey claims
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af82e/af82ef3b87141972d23b038d9a8f5ee3460033ff" alt="EPA Uniformed police officers walking through a small crowd of people at the carnival"
A majority of police officers feel unsafe working at Notting Hill Carnival, a survey by the Metropolitan Police Federation has suggested.
As part of the survey, officers who have worked at the event over the last 10 years described it as âhellâ and a âwarzoneâ.
There were more than 350 violent or sexual offences reported at the carnival in August, including the fatal stabbing of young mother Cher Maximen, according to the Met Police, and 61 attacks on officers.
However, the carnivalâs organiser said the survey had an âan anti-carnival agendaâ and only represented the views of a minority of the 7,000 officers who work at the event.
Notting Hill Carnival Ltd said the survey was âhugely flawedâ as it returned the views of âat best just 7% of potential officers on dutyâ.
In a survey of 486 officers, 89% said they did not feel safe and 29% said they been assaulted while policing the event.
The federation, which represents rank and file officers, said the poll aimed to get âconcrete evidenceâ of the experience of officers.
The carnival â a celebration of Caribbean culture â takes place along a three-and-a-half mile (5.6km) route in north Kensington, west London, and has been running for more than 50 years.
âDangerousâ
Held over each August bank holiday, the display of costumes, dancing and music attracts about two million revellers.
The running of the event has been criticised in recent years over what police call âan unacceptable level of crimeâ, but some supporters of the carnival claim it has been unfairly portrayed.
One unnamed officer said it was âdangerousâ, with officers being treated as âlambs to slaughterâ, while another said they would âwould rather crawl naked through broken glassâ than work there.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/de953/de953a0b482431bc77b3f57e10abc7622a3ecf09" alt="Reuters A black woman in a dazzling costume dances near a Tube station on the parade route"
Simon Hill, deputy general secretary of the Metropolitan Police Federation, said: âIâm actually quite shocked by some of the responses. I knew that the event wasnât popular, for a whole variety of reasons.
âBut the candour from the officers and some of their descriptions of how they feel, how they felt at the carnival and their experiences of being assaulted, quite frankly were shocking.â
The federation is also concerned the large scale of the event meant officers felt âpowerlessâ to prevent those attending the event becoming victims of crime, Mr Hill said.
âNo other event in London has this combination or level of issues for officers.â
He said officersâ concerns about long working hours also emerged from the survey.
âAnti-carnival agendaâ
The event organiser said it condemned âall acts of violenceâ and said the results of the survey were âmisleadingâ.
âIt is quite clearly written with an anti-carnival agenda that the police federation highlights every year. It is driven by unsubstantiated quotes and little solid data, designed to create negative headlines,â Notting Hill Carnival Ltd said.
A spokesperson added that organisers rely on the collaboration with police and local authorities, but âthis continued rhetoric unquestionably has a detrimental effect on the events planning processâ.
The Metropolitan Policeâs Deputy Assistant Commissioner Matt Ward said: âThe views described in the survey reflect many of the long-standing concerns about crowd safety and crime at Notting Hill Carnival.
âThey also highlight recent positive changes to officer provision which we know we need to continue to build on.â
He said the force was concerned by âunacceptable levels of crime at the eventâ and that âstep changeâ was needed in the running of the event to prevent overcrowding.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio London on Sounds and follow BBC London on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to hello.bbclondon@bbc.co.uk