Police mistakenly refused to divulge abuse history
A journalist was âmistakenlyâ told by police weeks before her death that she was not entitled to know if her former partner had any history of domestic abuse, an inquest has heard.
Granada Reports news editor Teresa McMahon was found dead at her flat in Salford in August 2021, not long after she had reported to Greater Manchester Police (GMP) that she had had her fingers and potentially one of her ribs broken.
The 43-year-oldâs ex-partner, Robert Chalmers, gave evidence by video-link from Bolton after he was arrested for failing to appear at her inquest in London. He denied either hurting her physically or trying to control her.
Coroner Mary Hassell concluded Ms McMahon had taken her own life and that âno other person forced her to do thatâ.
âClareâs Lawâ
She said: âI donât have any evidence that any other person physically caused Teresaâs death.â
The court heard Ms McMahon asked GMP on 12 July 2021 to disclose information about any history of violence or abuse from Mr Chalmers.
Giving evidence at the inquest, Det Insp Charlotte Poole said a junior GMP officer had âmistakenlyâ told Ms McMahon nine days later that she was not entitled to this information under Clareâs Law because she was not currently in a relationship with him.
Officers unsuccessfully tried to get in touch with Ms McMahon the next day and again on 29 July to tell her she might be entitled to receive the information.
Det Insp Poole also told the inquest that during the 21 July police visit, Ms McMahon had made a âcomplaint of broken fingers and a potentially broken rib but had not sought medical attention for those injuriesâ and did not wish to assist in a prosecution of Mr Chalmers.
She said: âItâs not unusual for domestic abuse victims to not want to assist in a prosecution once theyâve made that report.â
Ms Poole revealed Mr Chalmers had been named in âthree logsâ of domestic abuse reports over an 11-year-period.
These were not necessarily convictions â they could have been accusations or intelligence reports.
Mr Chalmers accepted his relationship with Ms McMahon had been volatile, but said he did not hurt her physically, nor coerce or control her.
Asked by the coroner if he thought unhappiness with their relationship was a factor in her death, Mr Chalmers replied: âNo.â
Ms Hassell asked Det Insp Poole if GMP had considered the possibility Ms McMahon might have killed herself due to being subjected to coercive control.
She replied âthere was nothing to indicate she wasâ.
Det Ch Insp Gareth Humphreys told the inquest âno defence injuriesâ had been found on Ms McMahonâs body.
He said a journal written by her, seen by police, referred to âreasons why she wanted to dieâ.
Dr Muhammad Bashir, who carried out Ms McMahonâs post-mortem examination, told the inquest there was no indication anyone else had been involved in her death.
Det Con Max Baimak said in a statement, read out to the inquest, there were âno malicious or threatening communications between Teresa and Robertâ.
It added Ms McMahon had messaged Mr Chalmers on 2 August, writing âI wish I was deadâ.
In another message she wrote: âIâve got nothing. Iâve never felt so worthless,â with Mr Chalmers later replying: âYou have and do so much Teresa.â
He also messaged âHope youâre OK Teresaâ and âLet me know youâre OKâ.
âVery generousâ
Ms McMahonâs father, Bernard, said he thought her death was the âtragic combination of being in a bad relationship, drinking too much alcohol and suffering depressionâ.
In a written statement read out to court, he said: âThere was screaming, shouting and threats made between them both, but I donât believe there was any physical abuse or controlling behaviour.â
He described his daughter as âdrivenâ and âvery generousâ.
Ms McMahonâs aunt, Lorna McMahon, told the court her brother âwas lyingâ, adding he was âfriends with Robert Chalmersâ.
Ms Hassell said while the inquest was ânot a public inquiry into GMPâ, the police investigation into her death was ânot perfectâ.
In a statement issued after the inquest, Assistant Chief Constable Steph Parker said GMP had âaddressed concerns raised by the coroner around the benefit of scene photos in non-suspicious circumstances, and clearer retention periods for body-worn videoâ.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas to northwest.newsonline@bbc.co.uk and via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.