School leaders know fixing problems a marathon, not a sprint
If one thing was clear from the emails that came pouring in after the autumn Budget, itâs that school leaders and other education experts see fixing problems in Englandâs education system as a marathon, not a sprint.
Thatâs because there are big challenges. Universities warn theyâre at risk of going bust, targets have been missed for rebuilding crumbling schools, teachers are leaving the profession and the system designed to help children with special education needs and disabilities (Send) has been dubbed âbrokenâ.
What all these experts are not quite agreed on, however, is how quickly the government should be pacing itself at this early stage.
There are those who were hoping for a sprint start this week.
Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Education Union (NEU), which has led teacher walkouts in recent years, said new funding announcements were âinsufficientâ and the government needed to âmove much fasterâ.
The ÂŁ2.3bn increase to the core schools budget â a real-terms increase of 1.8%, according to the Education Policy Institute (EPI) â includes ÂŁ1bn for Send.
The ÂŁ1.3bn left over for mainstream schools would put head teachers in a âvery difficult positionâ, said Mr Kebede, given the struggles they have in recruiting teachers and keeping them in the job.
Others are conceiving of the Budget as something of a steady start â maybe a jog â and hope the pace will ramp up later on.
Julia Harnden of the Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL) said the ÂŁ300m announced for further education âdoes not match the governmentâs ambition for a major focus on skillsâ, and that the ÂŁ6.7bn for school and college buildings â including removing dangerous concrete and turning empty classrooms into nurseries â âdoes not cover the shortfall that already existsâ.
âAlthough there are many things in [Wednesdayâs] Budget to be positive about, there is an awful lot more to do and much of what we have heard represents relatively small spending commitments which do not match the level of investment that the education system requires,â she said.
Some think the government still has time to build up that pace, though, and should be looking ahead to the next spending review, due in the spring, as a milestone.
âThe extensive neglect of schools under Conservative governments meant it was always going to be difficult to give school leaders all the financial support they needed in this Budget alone,â said Paul Whiteman, general secretary of the school leadersâ union the NAHT.
âIt is a start based on good intentions, but it must be backed up by further ambition and investment in the multi-year spending review due next spring.â
David Hughes, chief executive of the Association of Colleges, said the Treasury had shown that it ârecognises the need to invest moreâ in further education this week, and that he hoped for a âbetter, longer-termâ plan next year.
âWe do not expect this picture to change overnight, but we do want the government to set out an investment plan for the next three to five years,â he said.
The EPI said any long-term plan for colleges should involve allocating funds based on the proportion of disadvantaged students who study there. âThis alone would cost ÂŁ340m a yearâ, it said â above what has been allocated for next year.
And as the government gets off the starting line with funding announcements, it will be acutely aware of calls for other whole-system reforms later on down the road.
The Local Government Association, which represents councils, wants to see âfundamental reform of the Send system, focusing on improving inclusion in mainstream settings and writing off councilsâ high-needs deficitsâ.
ASCL said a new Send plan was needed to âensure funding always gets to the frontlineâ, while the NEU said it was in discussions with the government about what reform should look like.
Universities, whose main calls for financial help were not met in this weekâs budget, also say they want to work with ministers on a new blueprint for higher education. They say decisions need to be made soon, including raising tuition fees in England in line with inflation.
Ministers are part-way through an expansion of free childcare hours â a reform brought in under the Conservatives that will remain under close scrutiny, particularly as the ÂŁ1.8bn announced by the chancellor last weekend was actually pledged by her predecessor, Jeremy Hunt.
As the government embarks on its marathon, every decision will have to be made against the backdrop of falling pupil numbers over the coming years â and that around 35,000 children could join the state sector as a result VAT being added to private schools.
Itâs a rocky road ahead.